Why LinkedIn Fails 80% of the Time When Hiring Internationally

Not interested in hearing from Lean Leverage or Go Carpathian?
Unsubscribe at the bottom of this email.

When most companies decide to hire internationally, their first instinct is to post a job on LinkedIn and wait for applications to roll in.

It seems logical. After all, LinkedIn is the world's largest professional network with over 1 billion users across 200 countries.

But here's the uncomfortable truth: LinkedIn is one of the least effective platforms for international hiring, especially for high-quality talent. 

Here’s why.

The LinkedIn International Hiring Gap

Emerging markets, countries experiencing rapid growth and industrialization like those in Eastern Europe, parts of Asia, Latin America, and Africa, represent some of the world's most dynamic talent pools. These regions are characterized by growing economies, expanding middle classes, and increasingly educated workforces.

Research from Korn Ferry's Global Talent Crunch study reveals that only 23% of international hires in emerging markets come through traditional job boards and platforms like LinkedIn.

This aligns with findings from the International Labour Organization, which found that in regions like Eastern Europe, South Africa, and Latin America, between 70-85% of professional placements happen through alternative channels.

Why does LinkedIn perform so poorly for international recruiting? Several key factors are at play:

1. Regional Platform Preferences

LinkedIn's global user base is heavily skewed toward North America and Western Europe:

• LinkedIn penetration in the US: 65% of professionals

• LinkedIn penetration in Eastern Europe: 27% of professionals

• LinkedIn penetration in South Africa: 21% of professionals

• LinkedIn penetration in Latin America: 19% of professionals

(Source: DataReportal Global Digital Overview, 2023)

This means when you're recruiting exclusively through LinkedIn, you're missing access to 73-81% of the talent pool in these regions.

2. Cultural Job-Seeking Differences

The Boston Consulting Group's Global Talent Survey found significant regional differences in how professionals search for jobs:

• In Eastern Europe, 64% of professionals rely on personal networks and regional job boards

• In South Africa, 58% use industry-specific platforms and referrals

• In Latin America, 71% find opportunities through local professional associations and regional platforms

LinkedIn simply doesn't align with how most international professionals actually find work.

3. Algorithm Bias Toward US Profiles

A Stanford University study on global recruiting platforms found that LinkedIn's algorithms favor profiles that match US formatting and keyword patterns, creating an inherent disadvantage for international candidates.

International profiles receive 47% less visibility in search results compared to equivalent US profiles, even when they match the same search criteria.

📧Your Business Needs a Newsletter
Orbit Marketing has launched lead-generating newsletters for dozens of founders, agency owners, and creators. They'll work with you 1:1 to:

• Pin down your positioning, voice, and editorial calendar
• Handle the tech: ESP setup, templates, automations, and design
• Write, edit, and publish your first 12 issues with unlimited revisions 

Get your newsletter right the first time. 👉 Apply here (limited spots available)

Why Eastern Europe, South Africa, and Latin America?

These regions offer exceptional value for companies looking to build global teams:

Eastern Europe

• Technical Excellence: Eastern European countries consistently rank in the top 20 globally for STEM education (OECD Education Rankings, 2023)

• Digital Infrastructure: Countries like Romania and Bulgaria offer some of the fastest internet speeds globally, outpacing many US cities (Speedtest Global Index, 2023)

• Cultural Alignment: Strong cultural compatibility with Western business practices and work ethics

• Language Proficiency: 91% of professionals under 35 speak business-level English (EF English Proficiency Index, 2023)

South Africa

• Business Communication: English is the primary business language, eliminating communication barriers

• Time Zone Advantage: South Africa's time zone overlaps with both European and US business hours

• Sales Expertise: Particularly strong in client-facing roles like sales and customer success

• Growing Tech Hub: Cape Town and Johannesburg have emerged as major tech centers with deep talent pools

Latin America

• Proximity: Similar time zones to the US make real-time collaboration seamless

• Cultural Familiarity: Strong cultural ties to the US market and consumer behaviors

• Technical Education: Countries like Brazil, Argentina, and Colombia produce over 100,000 STEM graduates annually

• Bilingual Talent: High availability of English-Spanish bilingual professionals

The Multi-Channel Advantage

Companies that successfully hire internationally use multiple sourcing channels:

• Regional job boards specific to target countries

• Direct outreach to employed professionals

• Local professional networks and associations

• Industry-specific forums and communities

The Global Recruiting Trends Report by Manpower Group found that companies using four or more sourcing channels for international hiring were 3.2x more likely to find high-quality candidates than those relying on a single platform like LinkedIn.

How Go Carpathian Overcomes the LinkedIn Limitation

Our four-funnel recruiting approach is specifically designed to access the 80% of international talent that LinkedIn misses:

1. Regional Job Boards: We post on country-specific platforms where local professionals actually look for work.
   

2. Direct Headhunting: We proactively identify and approach employed professionals who aren't actively job hunting and rarely maintain updated LinkedIn profiles.
   

3. Targeted Content Marketing: We create region-specific content that attracts passive candidates through channels they actually use daily.
   

4. Referral Networks: We leverage our extensive connections in key regions to tap into the "hidden job market.”

Membership: Insurance for Your Hiring

Our membership works like insurance for your hiring. While our standard contracts come with a 120-day guarantee, as long as you're on membership, we will replace free of charge any person that we've ever hired for you.

Think of it this way: you insure your office, your equipment, your operations, why not insure your most important investment? Your team.

With membership, Go Carpathian becomes your partner in making sure that you stay fully staffed. No time limits. No additional fees. Complete protection for every hire we've ever made for you.

What you get:

• Five additional roles included

• Unlimited replacement guarantee (vs. 120 days standard)

• Free replacement of any person we've ever hired for you

• Go Carpathian as your staffing partner

Ready to access 80% of international talent that LinkedIn misses? Let's talk about finding exceptional professionals for your team.

Free Discovery Call with Recruiting Specialist

Until next time,

Nathan

Thanks for reading! Here are three ways to work with me:

1. Hire my Recruiting Company to find you the top 1% of talent from the US, Eastern Europe, South Africa, and Latin America

2. Hire my SEO agency to ethically steal all of your competitors’ Google Search Traffic

3. Book 30 minutes of my time to save at least $57,000 in payroll and hiring costs.